The choice between air core and laminated iron core inductors has been a long-running debate. Usually, it is recommended that iron core inductors be used ONLY in low-frequency drivers due to distortion and core saturation.
The debate here is that this is a long-running fallacy and leads to higher component costs due to the use of large air-core inductors when not needed.
The choice between air core and laminated iron core inductors has sparked a long-running debate in the audio community. Traditionally, it was believed that iron core inductors were suitable only for low-frequency drivers due to concerns about distortion and core saturation. However, let's dispel these misconceptions and explore the actual considerations when choosing between the two.
EMI: Electromagnetic interference (EMI) is rarely an issue for audio frequencies, making it a non-concern for both air core and iron core inductors.
Distortion: When properly rated and designed for audio applications, both types of inductors exhibit negligible distortion in the 20 Hz to 20 kHz audio range. Within this frequency range, they perform well without significant degradation.
Phase Shift: While inductors can introduce phase shifts, those in the audio range (20 Hz to 20 kHz) are generally minor and considered negligible for typical speaker crossovers and audio systems.
Magnetic Storage: The notion of a "stored magnetic charge" causing signal smearing is not substantiated. Inductors do store energy as a magnetic field, but it does not directly cause smearing of the audio signal.
In summary, the impact of inductors in audio systems primarily revolves around their inductance value and impedance characteristics. While minor differences can arise between air core and iron core inductors, for most audio applications within the 20 Hz to 20 kHz range, their effects are minimal and won't significantly impact sound quality or system performance. Other factors, like inductance value, current handling, size, and cost, are often more crucial when choosing the appropriate inductor for your audio setup.